Can hosting a marathon in Riyadh increase the number of emergency room visits?
How has imposing additional taxes on sugary drinks in Saudi Arabia affected diabetes rates?
What was the impact of the 2012 public smoking ban on heart disease rates in Saudi Arabia?
How did the mandatory childhood vaccination policy introduced in the 1960s by Saudi Health Minister Dr. Hamed Al-Hersani affect childhood disease and mortality rate?
Has banning the sale of antibiotics without a prescription in Saudi Arabia helped reduce bacterial resistance?
Answering these questions doesn’t require laboratory experiments or traditional clinical trials Instead, they can be explored by analyzing data after such events occur. This method assesses the impact of human interventions, such as new laws or policies. These research opportunities provide valuable insights for healthcare decision-makers.
------------
What is a Natural Experiment in Medicine?
A natural experiment is an observational study used to assess the effects of policy changes or other external factors. Unlike randomized controlled trials, researchers do not assign participants to different groups. Instead, a real-world event—such as a new law—creates a situation where people are naturally divided into two groups.
• Intervention group – those affected by the policy or change.
• Control group – those who were not affected.
By comparing these groups, researchers can draw important conclusions about the impact of the intervention.
The reliability of these studies depends on the assumption that the two groups are similar in all relevant ways, as if they had been randomly assigned. This enhances the credibility of the findings.
-------------
Example of a Natural Experiment in Saudi Arabia Reem Al-Sukait 's Study on Sugary Drink Taxes
Reem Al-Sukait , a policy expert with a PhD from Tufts University, works with the World Bank to develop health policies. She conducted an analysis based on a natural experiment to assess the impact of Saudi Arabia’s selective tax on sugary beverages.
Her study found that purchases of soft drinks and energy drinks dropped by 58% in 2018 compared to 2016, following the introduction of the tax. These findings align with global evidence showing that taxing sugary drinks helps reduce consumption, which in turn can lower obesity rates, type 2 diabetes, and cardiovascular diseases.
---------------
Are Natural Experiments Reliable?
While natural experiments do not offer absolute proof of cause-and-effect relationships—since researchers cannot control all variables—they are still a powerful research tool. They are widely used in public health, behavioral economics, and education because they provide valuable data on the effects of policies and interventions.
-----------------
Global Examples of Natural Experiments in Health
1- Public Smoking Ban in Helena, Montana
A study in Helena, Montana, examined how banning smoking in public places affected heart attack hospitalizations. Helena served as the intervention area, while nearby regions acted as the control. Researchers observed a significant drop in heart attack hospital admissions during the six months the ban was in effect.
2- The Impact of a Norepinephrine Drug Shortage on Mortality Rates
Researchers studied a nationwide shortage of norepinephrine, a drug used to treat septic shock, as a natural experiment. They compared death rates among sepsis patients before, during, and after the shortage. The findings highlighted the drug’s critical role in reducing mortality.
------------------
Strengths and Weaknesses of Natural Experiments
(Strengths)
- Cost-effective, especially when using existing national data.
- Useful for answering research questions that cannot be studied through traditional methods due to ethical or logistical constraints.
(Weaknesses)
- Cannot fully prove causation, as external factors may influence outcomes.
- Relies on observational data, which may have limitations.
-------------------
How Can We Identify Natural Experiments in the Real World?
Natural experiments occur frequently, but recognizing and analyzing them requires careful research. By linking available data to relevant health outcomes, researchers can uncover valuable insights. Many of these studies rely on pre-existing real-world data, making data analysis and exploration essential tools in health research.
-------------------------
The Future of Natural Experiments in Saudi Arabia
Saudi Arabia’s rapidly advancing technology sector provides an opportunity to leverage data more effectively. Emerging initiatives such as digital twins, electronic health record integration, centralized health monitoring systems, and unified patient records will create a wealth of data for analyzing the impact of new health policies.
As these digital advancements grow, health policy research in Saudi Arabia is expected to flourish, offering new opportunities for improving healthcare services and policy decisions.
Microsoft Dragon Copilot provides the healthcare industry’s first unified voice AI assistant that enables clinicians to streamline clinical documentation, surface information and automate tasks.
How can the concept of Value-based Healthcare reshape the future of healthcare? 
